Most parenting programs aim to teach parents how to reduce their children’s disruptive behavior. New research looked at more than 150 studies of these programs, finding differences in what works best according to whether or not children already showed behavior problems.
The work was conducted by researchers at the University of Amsterdam, Cardiff University, University of Oxford, and Utrecht University. It appears in the journal Child Development, a publication of the Society for Research in Child Development.
Patty Leijten, assistant professor of child development at the University of Amsterdam, who led the study explained:
“We found that when severely disruptive behavior had already emerged in children, a combination of teaching parents how to manage behavior along with relationship-building strategies was more effective than just teaching parents how to manage behavior.
“However, when disruptive behavior had not yet emerged as a problem, teaching parents both strategies was not more helpful than teaching behavior-management strategies alone.”
Severely disruptive behavior was defined as openly uncooperative and hostile behavior, including frequent temper tantrums, excessive arguing with adults, and deliberate attempts to annoy or upset others.
Behavior-management strategies include praise to increase positive behavior and negative consequences, like timeouts to reduce disruptive behavior. Relationship-building strategies include encouraging parents to be sensitive to their children’s needs.
The researchers looked at 156 studies on the effectiveness of parenting programs for reducing disruptive behavior in children ages 2-10; the studies involved more than 15,000 families from a range of socioeconomic backgrounds in 20 countries.
Because the programs varied by whether they taught parents just behavior-management strategies or both relationship-building and behavior management strategies, the study could compare the effectiveness of these commonly used approaches.
G.J. Melendez-Torres, senior lecturer in social sciences and health at the University of Cardiff, who coauthored the study said:
“Policymakers and service providers should be aware that different families may need different strategies to reduce disruptive behavior in children. Programs designed to prevent severe disruptive behavior and to treat severe disruptive behavior may require different approaches.
“Adding relationship building to behavior management may benefit children who have not yet developed severe disruptive behavior in other ways, such as encouraging better overall communication between parents and children, but it doesn’t help reduce disruptive behavior in these children.
“However, for children who have already developed severe disruptive behavior, adding relationship building to behavior management is key to reducing these problems.”
Provided by: Society for Research in Child Development [Note: Materials may be edited for content and length.]
Like this article? Subscribe to our weekly email for more!