Have Farmers in China Got It Right?

Expanding monoculture threatens valuable services from land, such as flood control, water purification, and climate stabilization. A new approach promises to protect these benefits, while improving biodiversity and human livelihoods in rural areas around the world. (Image: via pixabay / CC0 1.0)

A new strategy being rolled out in China suggests that farmers can do much more than harvest crops. The idea is that well-managed, diverse agricultural lands can provide flood control, water purification, and climate stabilization, among other valuable services.

A recent case study by researchers at Stanford, McGill University, and the Chinese Academy of Sciences provides a promising demonstration of this approach — farmers who took environmental concerns into account doubled their incomes and reduced reliance on a single harvest, while also gaining environmental benefits from the land.

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Receive selected content straight into your inbox.

The group said the approach could help farmers worldwide protect both the environment and their livelihoods. Gretchen Daily, co-founder and faculty director of the Stanford Natural Capital Project, said:

Daily was senior author on a paper describing the results, published the week of April 1 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

An island test case

Working with government authorities, the researchers looked at how their proposed approach, called the “Ecological Development Strategy,” could work in Hainan Island, a rural, tropical region where expanding rubber plantations have driven extensive loss of natural forest and its vital benefits, such as soil retention and flood mitigation.

Although the economy grew due to the plantations, intensive monocropping practices increased sediment runoff and channeled agricultural chemicals into surface waters. Forest recreation and tourism disappeared. Flooding was exacerbated by the area’s loss of trees. The researchers looked at land use and land cover changes in Hainan Island over a 19-year period of steady rubber plantation growth.

Stanford biologist Gretchen Daily and study lead author Hua Zheng conduct research on a conventional plantation in Hainan, China. (Image: Zhiyun Ouyang)
Stanford biologist Gretchen Daily and study lead author Hua Zheng conduct research on a conventional plantation in Hainan, China. (Image: Zhiyun Ouyang)

Pairing that information with survey data from households, the team used the Natural Capital Project’s InVEST modeling software to understand how changes in land use management could have garnered different results in a natural forest or economic prosperity. Alongside the historical land data of almost two decades, the models helped researchers understand what could have happened if the land had never been developed for rubber plantations or if the plantations had been managed differently.

In particular, the researchers looked at one key land management change — a technique called intercropping that involves cultivating other valuable plants in the understory of a main crop. They found that rubber farmers who did this maintained the same production levels as monoculture plantations while significantly increasing soil retention, flood mitigation, and nutrient retention.

Perhaps most strikingly, farmers who took this approach doubled their incomes due to revenue from the additional crops. By diversifying their land, farmers also insured themselves against the risk of a single crop’s harvest failing or losing market value — key vulnerabilities of the monoculture system.

Broader applications

Central to the Chinese Ecological Development Strategy is a focus on targeted investments in nature. Identifying places like Hainan, where policy and management decisions can support both the economy and environment, is crucial to achieving the widespread impacts that China is looking for. According to the researchers, this study illustrates how regions can leverage natural resources to support economic growth without sacrificing ecosystem health or human well-being.

A rubber tree in a monoculture plantation in Hainan, China. (Image: Chris Colvin)
A rubber tree in a monoculture plantation in Hainan, China. (Image: Chris Colvin)

The challenges that Hainan rubber plantation farmers face in terms of relying on single crops are magnified at a global scale, where monocultures, such as soy, beef, and palm oil, drive the vast majority of the global food market. Global climate insecurity, water contamination, and species mass extinction are the result. The study’s authors emphasize that the science and practices exist to help drive a shift away from monoculture systems worldwide, and economic incentives await those who do. Daily said:

Provided by: SARAH CAFASSO/Stanford University [Note: Materials may be edited for content and length.]

Like this article? Subscribe to our weekly email for more!     

Recommended Stories

White radishes.

Foods to Keep Your Lungs Healthy in Winter

The novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV), which originated in Wuhan, is spreading fast. Apart from preventive measures ...

A black hole consuming its companion star.

Black Holes Eat Stars in Variable Mood Lighting

When a black hole chews up a star, it produces visible light or X-rays, but ...

A black hole near a red giant star.

Scientists May Have Just Discovered a New Class of Black Holes

Black holes are an important part of how astrophysicists make sense of the universe — ...

A young Chinese girl wearing a mask.

Liberation From the Wuhan Epidemic

The Wuhan coronavirus epidemic in mainland China is spreading across the land at an alarming ...

A patient with caronavius.

China Coronavirus Could Trigger Pandemic: Harvard Epidemiologist

Dr. Eric Feigl-Ding, a Harvard epidemiologist and health economist, has warned that the Chinese coronavirus ...

Chinese wearing masks.

How Is the Coronavirus Spreading Across the Globe?

The first case of a novel strain of coronavirus has been confirmed in the United ...

Chiang Kai-shek.

How Formal Education in China Was Ruined by Communism

Before 1949, Chinese society, especially university education in China under the Republic of China, enjoyed ...

Dominic Barton.

Canada’s Ambassador to China Says Relations Chilled After Huawei Executive’s Arrest

Dominic Barton, Canada’s ambassador to China, recently testified before the special House of Commons committee ...

A young Chinese boy.

A Sordid Tale of Raising a Child in Communist China

Kirsty Needham is a journalist who works as the China correspondent for The Sydney Morning ...

Send this to a friend