Musical Fumble and the Amazing Recovery During Tchaikovsky Finals

The Tchaikovsky competition in Moscow.

At the finals of the 16th International Tchaikovsky Competition in Moscow, a pianist from China was faced with a difficult situation when he ended up playing a concerto different from what the orchestra was playing. (Image: Screenshot via YouTube)

At the finals of the 16th International Tchaikovsky Competition in Moscow, a pianist from China was faced with a difficult situation when he ended up playing a concerto different from what the orchestra was playing. To the surprise of the audience, the pianist quickly recovered.

The confusion

Twenty-year-old An Tienxiu was supposed to play Tchaikovsky’s Piano Concerto No. 1 in the finals. As the orchestra started, he enthusiastically worked on his piano. But very soon, he realized that someone had mixed up the notes, putting up Tchaikovsky’s concerto in front of Tienxiu and Rachmaninoff’s Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini in front of every other orchestra member. Even the conductor was performing on Rachmaninoff’s notes.

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Receive selected content straight into your inbox.

Tienxiu was initially confused by the variation of notes and soon became dismayed, unable to play. After the initial shock, he successfully changed his performance to match what the orchestra was playing and ended the rhapsody in complete harmony. The chairman of the jury, Denis Matsuev, asked the Chinese pianist whether he would like to repeat his performance. But Tienxiu declined. The employee who was responsible for mixing up the notes was fired.

Tienxiu was initially confused at the variation of notes and soon became dismayed, unable to play.
Tienxiu was initially confused at the variation of notes and soon became dismayed, unable to play. (Image: Screenshot via YouTube)

The mishap cost Tienxiu a potential first prize in the piano category worth US$30,000. Instead, he ended up in fourth and was awarded a diploma. Tienxiu was also given a special prize for the courage he displayed by regaining self-composure even though the notes were mixed up. First place went to Alexandre Kantorow from France.

The second spot was shared between Mao Fujita from Japan and Dmitry Shishkin from Russia. There was a 3-way tie for third place between Konstantin Yemelyanov and Alexei Melnikov from Russia and Kenneth Broberg from the United States. A total of 45 musicians from about 19 different countries were given prizes in multiple categories at the competition. The event ended with the laureates performing a concert at the Zaryadye Concert Hall in Moscow.

Tchaikovsky’s interesting life

The competition is named after the famous Russian composer Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky. Born in 1840, Tchaikovsky started taking piano lessons when he was just 5 years old. Over the course of his life, he went on to create numerous compositions that received acclaim all across the globe. In 1884, the Emperor of Russia awarded a lifetime pension in recognition of his contribution to Russian music.

In 1884, Tchaikovsky was awarded a lifetime pension by the Emperor of Russia in recognition of his contribution to Russian music.
In 1884, Tchaikovsky was awarded a lifetime pension by the Emperor of Russia in recognition of his contribution to Russian music. (Image: via Wikimedia Commons)

Unfortunately, despite the joy Tchaikovsky created with his compositions, his personal life was not happy. He is said to have been constantly suffering from depression and was obsessively worried about getting ill. Tchaikovsky had a phobia of unbottled water. Whenever he conducted an orchestra, Tchaikovsky thought that his head was going to fall off. As such, he often held up his head with one hand during an orchestral performance, which was a weird thing to do in those times.

In 1877, Tchaikovsky married his former student. The relationship turned out to be tedious, causing several nervous breakdowns. Within a few weeks of marriage, the couple separated. Tchaikovsky had a patroness in Nadezhda von Meck, a widow of a railway baron. She supported him both emotionally and financially for 13 years. During this time, they exchanged almost 1,200 letters. However, they only met once in 1879.

Follow us on XFacebook, or Pinterest

Recommended Stories

A birdseye view of some Hong Kong school students during an excursion.

Hong Kong Students to Have More Compulsory ‘Red’ Study Trips to Mainland China

In April 2023, Hong Kong’s Chief Secretary Eric Chan bid farewell to about 200 Hong ...

Mr. Yang.

Successful Entrepreneurs in China Lose Everything on Trumped-Up Charges (Part 1)

Mr. Yang, one of China’s highly successful entrepreneurs now living in exile, recounted how he ...

A closeup view of jail cell iron bars casting shadows on the prison floor.

Successful Entrepreneurs in China Lose Everything Overnight on Trumped-Up Charges (Part 2)

Mr. Yang said persecuted entrepreneurs like him are too numerous in his home province and ...

Stir-fried pebbles.

Stir-Fried Pebbles: Chinese Vendors Are Making a Dish Made of Stones

Chinese street food vendors have amused the world by creating a unique cuisine; stir-fried pebbles, ...

Chinese painting of Kou Zhun, an official during the Northern Song Dynasty.

The Inspirational Story of Kou Zhun’s Mother: A Lesson in Moral Education

China, with its 5,000-year-old civilization, has always been recognized for the importance it places on ...

Man and woman in a heated argument.

Disagreeing Gracefully: How To Foster Understanding in a Polarized World

Most of us have found ourselves embroiled in a heated disagreement, feeling so hurt or ...

Exoplanet K2-18b.

Signs of Life? Why Astronomers Are Excited About Carbon Dioxide and Methane in the Atmosphere of an Alien World

Are we alone? This question is nearly as old as humanity itself. Today, this question ...

The tower in Kaiyuan Temple with cherry blossoms.

Historical Tale From China: Murong Yanchao Outsmarts a Swindler

During the Later Han Dynasty (947-950), Yunzhou’s leading commander, Murong Yanchao, was celebrated for his ...

A basket of eggs.

Reviving the Simple Long-Lost Art of Roasting Eggs

Roasting eggs is probably the most ancient way of cooking eggs. About 1 million years ...

Send this to a friend