All Comets in Our Solar System May Have Come From the Same Place

Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko.

This single frame Rosetta navigation camera image of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko was taken on July 7, 2015 from a distance of 154 km from the comet center. (Image: ESA/Rosetta/NAVCAM )

All comets might share their place of birth, new research says. For the first time ever, astronomer Christian Eistrup applied chemical models to 14 well-known comets, surprisingly finding a clear pattern. His publication has been accepted in the journal Astronomy & Astrophysics.

Balls of ice or more?

Comets travel through our solar system and are composed of ice, dust, and small rock-like particles. Their nuclei can be as large as tens of kilometers across. Eistrup said:

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Receive selected content straight into your inbox.

Comets travel through our solar system and are composed of ice, dust, and small rock-like particles.
Comets travel through our solar system and are composed of ice, dust, and small rock-like particles. (Image: via NASA)

A new take on comets

“What if I apply our existing chemical models to comets?” Eistrup thought during his Ph.D. at Leiden University. In the research team at Leiden Observatory, which included Kavli Prize winner Ewine van Dishoeck, he developed models to predict the chemical composition of protoplanetary discs — flat discs of gas and dust encompassing young stars.

Understanding these discs can give insight into how stars and planets form. Conveniently, these Leiden models turned out to be of help in learning about comets and their origins. Eistrup said:

This happened to be the case and to a surprising extent. Where the researchers hoped for a number of comets sharing similarities, it turned out that all 14 comets showed the same trend. “There was a single model that fitted each comet best, thereby indicating that they share their origin.”


And that origin is somewhere close to our young Sun, when it was still encircled by a protoplanetary disc and our planets were still forming. The model suggests a zone around the Sun, inside the range where carbon monoxide becomes ice — relatively far away from the nucleus of the young Sun.

But if comets come from the same place, how do they end up in different places and orbits in our solar system?

Comets are everywhere, and sometimes with very funky orbits around the Sun.
Comets are everywhere, and sometimes with very funky orbits around the Sun. (Image: via Wikimedia Commons)

Comet data hunter

As befits a scientist, Eistrup places some side notes to his publication.

Eistrup also hopes that astronomers that study the origin of our solar system and its evolution can use his results.

He is also keen to get in touch with other comet researchers.

The seeds of life

Comets and life on Earth go hand in hand. Eistrup concluded:

So, interestingly, understanding the birth of comets potentially could help us understand the birth of life on Earth.

Provided by: Bryce Benda, Leiden University [Note: Materials may be edited for content and length.]

Follow us on TwitterFacebook, or Pinterest

Recommended Stories

A girl reading a book.

Why Reading to Children is Important

Reading to children isn’t just a pastime or a spontaneous activity. It has many benefits ...

Shattering your fears.

6 Tips to Conquer Your Fears the Healthy Way

Fear is a normal reaction that helps people avoid dangerous situations or encounters. In instances ...

Flags of Australia, Canada, the U.S., the UK, and New Zealand with the image of an eye on them to symbolize the Five Eyes alliance.

The Highly Secretive Five Eyes Alliance Has Disrupted a China-Backed Hacker Group

This week the Five Eyes alliance — an intelligence alliance between Australia, the United Kingdom, ...

Melbourne, Australia.

Dependence on China: Australia at Most Risk Among Five Eyes

A study by London-based think tank the Henry Jackson Society has found that among all ...

Takaharu Tezuka-style kindergarten.

Combining Japanese Ingenuity With Kindergarten Design

A Japanese architect named Takaharu Tezuka wanted a kindergarten that kids would love. So he ...

Parents outside a Chinese kindergarten.

Chinese Media Ordered to Stop Reporting on Kindergarten Abuse

The Chinese government has ordered local media to halt coverage of a kindergarten abuse scandal ...

Giant trolls.

Thomas Dambo: The Artist Who Creates Giant Trolls Out of Trash

Thomas Dambo from Denmark has created something unique for the people of Copenhagen to enjoy ...

The Amazon rainforest.

Study Finds African Smoke Is Fertilizing Amazon Rainforest and Oceans

A new study led by researchers at the University of Miami’s (UM) Rosenstiel School of ...

A dead humpback whale.

Scientists Surprised at Finding a Dead Whale in the Amazon Rainforest

When thinking of whales, you would probably picture these majestic creatures in the oceans, surging ...

Send this to a friend