What Happens Below Earth’s Surface When the Most Powerful Earthquakes Occur

A cracked brick wall.

Like nearly all the of the most powerful earthquakes, this was a megathrust earthquake. These happen at subduction zones, places where one tectonic plate is forced under another. (Image: aitoff via Pixabay)

At 03:34 local time on February 27, 2010, Chile was struck by one of the most powerful earthquakes in a century. The shock triggered a tsunami, which devastated coastal communities. The combined events killed more than 500 people. So powerful was the shaking that, by one NASA estimate, it shifted Earth’s axis of spin by a full 8 cm.

Like nearly all of the most powerful earthquakes, this was a megathrust earthquake. These happen at subduction zones, places where one tectonic plate is forced under another. If the plates suddenly slip — wallop, you get a massive earthquake. The 2010 Chile quake was a magnitude 8.8 — strong enough to shift buildings off their foundations.

Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Receive selected content straight into your inbox.

We know that megathrust earthquakes are the result of the subduction of one tectonic plate below another.
We know that megathrust earthquakes are the result of the subduction of one tectonic plate below another. But beyond that, we have very little understanding of the dynamics of the subduction and how it might trigger an instability that leads to another megathrust earthquake a few years later. (Image: Angelo_Giordano via Pixabay)

We understand subduction zones poorly, which is why geophysicist Professor Anne Socquet, based at Université Grenoble Alpes in France, had planned to visit Chile. She wanted to install seismic monitoring instruments to collect data. By coincidence, she arrived just a week after the earthquake. She said:

“It was terrifying, the apartment we had rented had fissures in the walls that you could put your fist inside.’

Most people who study megathrust earthquakes focus on the foreshocks that immediately precede the main quake, Prof. Socquet says. But an unusual feature of megathrust earthquakes is that they are often followed by a series of other very powerful megathrust quakes several years later and with epicenters hundreds of kilometers away. The 2010 Chile quake, for instance, was followed by other events in 2014, 2015, and 2016 centered on areas up and down the Chile coast. Prof. Socquet wanted to look at these sequences of megathrust earthquakes and investigate the potential links between those great earthquakes. This requires a careful examination of seismological and geodetic data at a greater scale than has previously been done. 

Megathrust earthquakes

We know that megathrust earthquakes are the result of the subduction of one tectonic plate below another. But beyond that, we have very little understanding of the dynamics of the subduction and how it might trigger an instability that leads to another megathrust event a few years later. There is some evidence that it could be to do with the release and migration of fluids at great depth. Prof. Socquet’s DEEP-trigger project is about filling that gap. She said:

“This is kind of virgin territory in terms of observations.”

The first step of the 6-month-old project was supposed to be adding to the network of about 250 GPS instruments that she has contributed to in Chile since 2007 and building a new instrument network in Peru. Currently unable to travel to South America due to the COVID-19 pandemic, she’s been working with local contacts to begin the installation. She’s also working on computational tools to begin analyzing legacy data from the region, saying:

“The critical thing will be to have systematic observations of the link between the slow slip and the seismic fractures at large time and space scales. This will be a very big input to science.”

Prof. Alvaro has just demonstrated the first successful application of a combination of x-ray crystallography and a technique called Raman spectroscopy with a sample of a rock from a location known as the Mir pipe in Siberia. (Image: via Vladimir)

At the University of Pavia in Italy, mineralogist Professor Matteo Alvaro is also interested in megaquakes — albeit much, much older ones. It turns out that we can get a unique window on subduction zones as they were millions of years ago. There are certain places, few and far between, where rocks that have been through subduction zones are forced up to the surface. By analyzing these rocks, we can deduce the depths and pressures at which the subduction happened and build up a picture of how subduction works — and maybe how megathrust earthquakes are triggered.

Crystal

It usually works like this. Geologists find a rock made of a mineral with what’s called an inclusion crystal inside it. This inclusion was trapped inside the mineral as two subducting plates squeezed each other at great depth, perhaps 100 km or more below the surface. It will have a particular crystal structure — a specific, repeating spatial arrangement of atoms — which depends on the pressure it experienced as it formed. The crystal can reveal the pressure the inclusion was exposed to and hence the depth it was formed at.

The trouble is, this is an oversimplification. It only holds if the inclusion is cube-shaped — and it almost never is. This whole idea of pressure equals depth — we all know this might be incorrect, says Prof. Alvaro. “The natural question is, okay, but by how much are we wrong?” That’s what he decided to find out in his project TRUE DEPTHS.

A house destroyed in an earthquake.
It turns out that we can get a unique window on subduction zones as they were millions of years ago. There are certain places, few and far between, where rocks that have been through subduction zones are forced up to the surface. (Image: Angelo_Giordano
via Pixabay)

The plan was simple in principle. Prof. Alvaro wanted to measure the strain experienced by the crystal while still trapped inside the mineral. If he could understand the tiny displacement of the atoms from their usual positions in a typical, unpressurized crystal structure, that would provide a better measure of the stress applied by the surrounding rock as the crystal was formed and so a more accurate measure of the depth at which it was formed. To study the atomic structure, he uses a combination of X-ray crystallography and a technique called Raman spectroscopy.  

Prof. Alvaro has just demonstrated the first successful application of his techniques. He looked at a sample of a rock from a location known as the Mir pipe in Siberia. This is a shaft of molten kimberlite rock that rose very fast from huge depths. (We get most of our diamonds from kimberlite pipes like this, and indeed, Mir has been mined extensively.) Prof. Alvaro looked at rocks of garnet with tiny quartz inclusions inside that were brought up He said:

“The kimberlite is the elevator that brings it to the surface.”

Trigger

By measuring the strain on the inclusions, he could confirm it formed at a pressure of 1.5 gigaPascals (about 15,000 times that found at Earth’s surface) and a temperature of 850oC. This isn’t entirely surprising, but it is the first proof that Prof. Alvaro’s technique really works. He is now looking to make more measurements and build a library of examples.

He also wonders, more speculatively, if it’s possible that the formation and deformation of the inclusions might act as the very first trigger of megathrust earthquakes. The idea would be that these tiny changes set off cracks in larger rocks that eventually lead a fault to slip out of place. Prof. Alvaro is planning to explore this further, saying:

“No one knows what the initial trigger is, the thing that triggers the first slip. We started thinking — and maybe it’s a completely crazy idea — that maybe it’s these inclusions. A cluster of them, maybe subject to an instantaneous phase change and so a change in volume. Maybe that could be the very first trigger.”

Provided by: Caleb Davies, Horizon: The EU Research & Innovation Magazine [Note: Materials may be edited for content and length.]

Follow us on Twitter, Facebook, or Pinterest

Recommended Stories

Victoria Harbour Hong Kong.

3 Reasons Hong Kong Is Important to China: Money, Money, Money

With Hong Kong protests turning increasingly violent, Chinese media have been calling for stricter actions ...

The book 'Love Your Body.'

Book Review: ‘Love Your Body’ by Jessica Sanders

People have always been conscious of their bodies, spending countless hours worrying whether they were ...

The Khmer temples of Koh Ker.

Ground Radar Reveals Why Ancient Cambodian Capital Was Moved to Angkor

The largest water management feature in Khmer history was built in the 10th century as ...

The ancient city of Angkor Thom.

New Research Casts Doubt on Cause of Angkor’s Collapse

New University of Sydney research has revealed that the ancient Cambodian city of Angkor underwent ...

A young Hmong woman in traditioanl dress.

What Do You Know About the Hmong Community and Their Upcoming New Year?

The Hmong people are a community native to East and Southeast Asia. They hold a ...

Sayragul Sauytbay.

The Story of How a Kazakh Woman Survived China’s Re-education Camps

When talking about the persecution of Muslim minorities in China, the Uyghur community largely takes ...

Piles of dyed material.

How-to: Dyeing Your Clothes the Natural Way

There is a growing trend of people opting to dye their clothes using natural, plant-based ...

Hong Kong police accused of sexual violence.

Hong Kong Police Accused of Sexual Violence

On November 2, the Hong Kong democratic party held several election rallies with less than ...

The Huangtengxia Glass Corridor.

A Glass Corridor in China Featuring a Manmade Waterfall

In the Qingcheng District of Guangdong Province, the Chinese have created a unique structure that ...

Send this to a friend