Research Findings May Alter How Scientists Uncover Earth’s History as an Evolving Planet

A cave.
Collaborative National Research Centers on Integrating Tectonics, Climate, and Mammal Diversity. (Image: via Pixabay)

The Earth remains an evolving planet, and researchers at Stony Brook University are leading a research project that focuses on the interplay between the evolution of the landscape, climate, and fossil record of mammal evolution and diversification in the western United States. A little explored aspect of this geosciences research is the connection between gravitational forces deep in the Earth and landscape evolution.

In a newly published paper in Nature Communications, the researchers show by way of computer modeling that deep roots under mountain belts (analogous to the massive ice below the tip of an iceberg) trigger dramatic movements along faults that result in the collapse of the mountain belt and exposure of rocks that were once some 15 miles below the surface.

The history of Earth as an evolving planet

The origin of these enigmatic exposures, called metamorphic core complexes, has been hotly debated within the scientific community. However, this study finding may alter how scientists attempt to uncover the history of Earth as an evolving planet. Lead principal investigator William E. Holt, a professor of geophysics at the Department of Geosciences in the School of Arts and Sciences at Stony Brook University, first author Alireza Bahadori, a former Ph.D. student under Holt and now at Columbia University, and colleagues found that these core complexes are a fossil signature of past mountain belts in the western United States that occupied regions around Phoenix, Arizona, and Las Vegas, Nevada.

These visuals from Earth modeling illustrate metamorphic core complex development showing crustal stresses and strain rates, faults, uplift of deeper rocks, and sedimentation from surface erosion.
These visuals from Earth modeling illustrate metamorphic core complex development showing crustal stresses and strain rates, faults, uplift of deeper rocks, and sedimentation from surface erosion. These processes of core complex development occur after a thickened crustal root supporting topography is weakened through the introduction of heat, fluids, and partial melt. (Image: via Alireza Bahadori and William E. Holt)

These mountain areas left traces of gravel deposits from ancient northward and eastward flowing rivers, found today south and west of Flagstaff, Arizona. The work articulated in the paper highlights the development of what the research team terms a general model for metamorphic core complex formation and a demonstration that they result from the collapse of a mountain belt supported by a thickened crustal root. The authors further explain:

“We show that gravitational body forces generated by topography and crustal root cause an upward flow pattern of the ductile lower-middle crust, facilitated by a detachment surface evolving into a low-angle normal fault. Furthermore, this detachment surface acquires large amounts of finite strain, consistent with thick mylonite zones found in metamorphic core complexes.”

The work builds on research also published in Nature Communications in 2022. Holt and colleagues published a first-of-a-kind model in three dimensions to illustrate the linkage between climate and tectonics to simulate the landscape and erosion/deposition history of the region before, during, and after the formation of these metamorphic core complexes. This modeling was linked to a global climate model that predicted precipitation trends throughout the southwestern U.S. over time. The 3-D model accurately predicts sediment deposition in basins containing mammal fossils and climate records.

A representation of the model setup, boundary conditions, inputs, and outputs of simulations. ‘T’ is the sub-lithosphere tractions from mantle convection. ‘U’ is the 3-D displacement field for the upper crust. ‘P’ is the precipitation model.
A representation of the model setup, boundary conditions, inputs, and outputs of simulations. ‘T’ is the sub-lithosphere tractions from mantle convection. ‘U’ is the 3-D displacement field for the upper crust. ‘P’ is the precipitation model. (Image: via Alireza Bahadori and William E. Holt)

The group also published a paper in Science Advances in November 2021, led by team member Katie Loughney (Tectonic influence on Cenozoic mammal richness and sedimentation history of the Basin and Range, western North America). This research showed that a significant peak in mammal diversification could be statistically tied to the peak in the extensional collapse of the ancient mountain belts. Thus, the collaborative study is the first to quantify how deep Earth forces combine with climate to influence the landscape and impact mammal diversification and species dispersal found within the fossil record.

The study required the vast computing resources provided by the High-Performance Computing Cluster SeaWulf at Stony Brook University. In addition, the climate modeling, produced by Ran Feng, University of Connecticut, was supported by the Cheyenne supercomputer maintained at NCAR-Wyoming Supercomputing Center.

Provided by Stony Brook University [Note: Materials may be edited for content and length.]

Follow us on TwitterFacebook, or Pinterest

  • Troy Oakes

    Troy was born and raised in Australia and has always wanted to know why and how things work, which led him to his love for science. He is a professional photographer and enjoys taking pictures of Australia's beautiful landscapes. He is also a professional storm chaser where he currently lives in Hervey Bay, Australia.

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR YOU